| |
|
Throw away your 6-71 blower . . .
The Air Force Has Landed
Click on the "thumbnails" to see full-size pictures
PS: Sorry about the (lack of) scan quality
While the performances of today's Top Fuelers and Funny Cars are truly
impressive, often the problems encountered have been solved by simply using
a bigger hammer to pound the square peg in the round hole. Take the ever-present
GMC 6-71 Rootes-type supercharger for example. Originally designed to operate
at low rpm as a diesel exhaust extractor for buses and the like, it was pressed
into service by drag racers when they found that it was commercially available
at a tolerable cost. Where centrifugal superchargers, turbochargers and the
like all had an undesirable lag in terms of throttle response and low-end boost,
the 6-71 offered an immediate pressure boost.
But the 6-71 had a few shortcomings which drag racers, to this day, have
either overlooked or not cared to admit. While the Rootes-type blower works
on the positive-displacement principle, with lobes stuffing the air down into
the engine, it is also "friction city." The heat of compression and friction
caused by the impellers scraping against the inner case wall raises the temperature.
Heat-sensing thermocouples mounted in the intake manifold of a 6-71 superchraged
engine have recorded temperatures in excess of 250 degrees F.
We know that the amount of horsepower an engine creates is directly
proportional to the amount of fuel/air mixture it burns per minute. It follows
that if the fuel/air mixture is heated and expands before entering the combustion
chamber, it becomes less dense, which means that the engine burns less fuel/air
mixture. This, of course, means less horsepower.
Another discouraging aspect of the 6-71 blower is that it takes a lot
of power to spin the rotors. Accurate estimates peg a 6-71 blower with 33%
overdrive, mounted on an engine operating at 8000 rpm, as requiring between
250 to 300 horsepower to spin those rotors around. This power is sapped from
the engine. And when you go to higher rpm ranges of the 6-71 blower, its efficiency
takes a dump. In effect it requires more power to spin the blower than the
blower is adding to the engine.
Detonation is still another bad feature of today's nitro-burning supercharged
engines, although it doesn't necessarily have any connection with the 6-71 blower.
For one reason or another the charge of fuel in the combustion chamber is ignited
at some time prior to the instant the plug fires. This detonation literally
plays havoc with the bearings, rods, rod bolts, wrist pins and pistons, generally
messing up the otherwise smooth, ideal rotational operation of the engine.
So what would you say if we told you there was a way to provide a boost
for the engine without creating heat, which eliminated detonation, and which
didn't require one horsepower of the engine's output to operate? Well we wouldn't
lead you down the primrose path if we didn't have some sort of punch line.
It seems that aerospace engineer Bob Keane of Keane Engineering in Fullerton,
California, has been working for the past three years to develop a system of
pressurized air bottles to replace the 6-71 blower. The idea is to supply all
of the engine's air needs for a run from a number of scuba tanks filled with
2200 psi (pounds per square inch) of normal air. The tanks are secured in the
chassis in a location where the weight is desired for additional traction or
front-end ballast. The entire system, complete with bottles, doesn't weigh much
more than a complete 6-71 blower setup. Each tank contains approximately 80
cubic feet of compressed air.
Since the desired boost on a blown fuel engine varies between 14 and
22 psi, you can see that in order to make the concept feasible, the pressure
in the bottles must be reduced to match the needs of the engine. To accomplish
this, the key component of the system is an air pressure regulator which controls
the reduction of gas pressure from 2200 psi to 15 psi or so. This flow control
valve was originally built for use in ground systems tank pressurization (fueling)
of Titan and Saturn missiles, and was developed by Keane for that purpose. The
pressure regulator keeps the outlet pressure at the desired preset level with
an accuracy of plus or minus 1 psi, even though the inlet pressure is falling
from 2200 psi to 200-300 psi as the air supply is depleted at the completion
of the run.
Other components in the system in addition to the scuba bottles and the
air pressure regulator include a special high pressure Enderle fuel injection
"bugcatcher" unit (which also doubles as a plenum), an engine-driven fuel pump
with 10% overdrive, and a fuel-control valve which was also developed by Keane
for aerospace applications. Patents are pending on both of Keane's valves, as
well as on the entire system. All of the components in the system are functioning
below designed operating pressures and provide a maximum safety factor. As an
example, the bottles are capable of containing pressures of 8000 psi, or four
times the working pressure of Keane's system.
Initial testing of various forms of the system was done on three different
dragsters and one of Mickey Thompson's Ford Funny Cars, but in all instances,
no full quarter-mile runs were attempted. Recently, however, Keane got together
with Mickey Thompson and, utilizing Thompson's exotic dyno facility in Long
Beach, accomplished an exhaustive testing program. The results were phenomenal.
Where a 6-71 blown Boss 429 Ford engine on 20% nitro had produced 1360 horsepower,
the same type of engine equipped with the bottled air system in place of the
Rootes blower, burning only straight alcohol, produced 2400 horsepower at 6000
rpm! On gasoline, the system made about 1550 horsepower. This success was not
easily achieved, as in one week of testing, Thompson reportedly ran 150 gallons
of alcohol through the dyno engine.
If those horsepower figures sound a little too incredible for
you to believe, understand that there are several factors working in the bottled
air system's favor. First is the fact that the 250-300 horsepower previously
required to turn the 6-71 can now be put out at the flywheel for the driveline
to use. Secondly, because the thermal characteristics of alcohol are better
than those of nitromethane and the air fuel mixture is much cooler, detonation
is reduced to the point where it is almost entirely eliminated, making for a
smoother-running engine that produces more power.
Most important, however, is the fact that the engine will consume as
much alcohol as a 6-71 blown engine would consume nitro (remember that business
about horsepower being directly proportional to the amount of fuel/air mixture
consumed). In a normal 6-71 engine, not nearly as much alcohol would be used
as nitro during a quarter-mile run, but because the fuel/air mixture is considerably
cooler with the bottled air system than with the 6-71, the charge is much more
dense.
The reason the charge is cooler with the bottled air system is twofold.
First, you don't have that firction-producing air pump to heat the air up to
256 degrees. The air in the bottles is at room temperature. Secondly, when the
air is released from the bottles into the system and passed to the engine, it
encounters such a steep pressure drop (from 2200 psi to 16 psi) in such a short
period of time that the temperature of the air actually drops anywhere from
70 to 100 degrees below the ambient (room) temperature. So where the air coming
out of a 6-71 is above 250 degrees F., the air from the bottles is anywhere
from 0 to -30 degrees F. It is this densely packed charge of air/fuel mixture
that provides most of the extra power.
There are several interesting aspects to the system which should be noted.
When the engine is started and the car is driven to the line, it runs normally
aspirated (unblown). Small flapper doors open and allow normal atmospheric
pressure to supply the engine with air, even for the burnouts. But when the
car is staged and the driver is ready to make his pass down the quarter mile,
he presses the throttle "to the wood," activating a button which turns on the
system. The instant-pressurization causes the flapper doors to slam shut tight.
From then on, until the driver decides to stop using the system, the car runs
entirely on the air contained in the scuba tanks.
If the tanks run out of air, the flapper doors open and the engine runs
normally aspirated with no "lean out" explosions similar to those experienced
with 6-71 blowers. If the driver lifts the throttle at any time, the system
shuts off within .030 to .200 of a second, putting the engine back on a normally
aspirated status. If at any time the driver shuts off the ignition, the engine
stops running. When you go back to the pits, you just refill the bottles with
more compressed air. Another clever feature of the system is that any predetermined
amount of boost can be "dialed in." If you want anywhere from 8 to 50-psi boost,
just set the gauge before you run and the engine will be constantly fed just
that much boost.
You've probably surmised that fuel metering poses a tricky situation,
which it does. A fuel pressure control valve (compensator) senses the air flow
from the storage vessels to the engine manifold, and adjusts the fuel-flow
rates as a function of the air-flow rate to the engine. And when the engine
reaches higher rpm operation, the air flows out of the bottles at a faster
rate to supply the need, thus causing an even greater rate of pressure drop
and a denser charge as a result. The faster you use the air, the colder it
gets . . . just the opposite of the situation with the 6-71, which gets hotter
as it runs faster.
Despite the changing fuel/air mixture density, the fuel pressure control
valve compensates with a response time of only .030 of a second. All fuel is
injected into the engine through port nozzles in the manifold, and any preselected
fuel/air ratio can be maintained (five units of air to every one unit of alcohol
in this case). Interestingly enough, no matter what Thompson and Keane tried
on the dyno, they couldn't get the engine to lean out. It always ran on the
rich side, which means that the engine is always "safe." In all the dyno testing,
they have not damaged one engine part, despite the fact that they performed
50 simulated "runs" on the dyno. And in all the testing, the engine's leakdown
rate (compression sealing) didn't change at all!
The unit may be made commercially available, manufactured by Keane and
marketed through Mickey Thompson, and should sell for only slightly more than
the cost of a good 6-71, injection setup, blower drive and manifold (although
your present 6-71 intake manifold and port nozzles can be used with the system).
Considering the low fuel and air costs compared to the high price of nitro,
a racer should be able to save enough money in fuel costs over a period of
three months to pay for the unit. Another count in the bottle air system's
favor is the fact that engine breakage should be reduced, as well as the possibility
of a blower explosion/fire.
Just to make sure that some smart guy doesn't try to "cheat" with the
bottled air system by "hopping up" (increasing) the oxygen content of the air
in his bottles, Keane suggests that a small valve be included in the system
so that officials can take a sample of the air and analyze it, as they currently
do with gasoline, to see that the guy is playing it honest with "straight" air.
If drag strip testing of the system proves as successful as the dyno
results indicate it might, the sport is going to undergo a vast changeover as
far as equipment is concerned, since the 6-71 blower will go the way of the
flatheads. But a need will arrive for gobs of clutch, drivetrain and tire
development, as existing equipment will not begin to suit the demands of a
2500-horsepower Top Fueler or Funny Car.
| written by Terry Cook
from Car Craft magazine
page 36-37; 86-87 - December, 1971
© Petersen Publishing Co. Ltd. 1971 |
|
|
|